
I'm back in the city, and so is the humidity, which can only mean one thing: My search for the city's best frozen chocolate is back on.
I first moved to New York in August, when it was sweltering in the high nineties. While seeking refuge in
my favorite chocolate shop one day, to my delight I found they had cold chocolate to replace their warmer winter fare. Hot Cho is a major comfort food for me, and in need of warm-weather comforting in the big, steamy city, cold chocolate was there for me. It became something of an obsession. Here are my picks for the best cold cocoa in town.
1. Petite Abeille. If tiny shavings of rich chocolate blended and suspended in creamy milk sound bad to you, DO NOT go to Petite Abeille. Because the magical chocolate dust in this stuff melts in your mouth creating a perfectly rich, cool, creamy sip. It doesn't look fancy--the low-frills plastic cup looks like chocolate milk poured over ice. But when they pour this elixir out of unassuming punch pitchers you are in for a treat. Not too sweet and not even the littlest bit waxy, it really is as though the finest belgian chocolate truffles have been shaved, melted down, and served on ice. Simple with major chocolate power, RUN do not walk to Petite Abeille.
2. Mariebelle. This is hands-down my favorite hot chocolate when it's served warm (sorry City Bakery). It's almost like drinking a brownie. An insanely high-quality, slightly spicy, smooth brownie. Obviously I like my chocolate strong, and the frozen variety is served blended with crushed ice margarita-style, which makes it a little heavy on ice and milk and a little weak on chocolate for my tastes. Nonetheless, the chocolate is amazing and distinctive, with that little bit of Aztec chile bite in the back of the throat. Hard to pass up.
3. Serendipity 3. This is where it all supposedly began with Serendipity's "Frrrozen Hot Chocolate." First I'll say, it's pretty good. I mean, any cafe snobby enough to deny the recipe to Jacquelyn Kennedy for White House dinners is kind of awesome. The ice-to-chocolate ratio is good, the giant daubs of whipped cream are a perfect complement, and the fact that the whole thing is served up like a giant sundae in a parfait dish means they clearly take this stuff seriously. That said, I don't think I would ever wait two hours in line for this stuff. Okay so yes, I did once, and I never would again. So, if you must go to Serendipity, then get the chocolate. But otherwise, spare a few hours of your life and grab an equally good cold cho at one of these other places without the waits, and, allbeit, celeb gawking.
4. Cafe Lalo. This is another tourist fave ala "You've Got Mail" fame, but I still find it charming. More importantly, the frozen cho is quite delightful. It's light on the crushed ice, goes down easy, and is not as intense as some sister varieties. If you're a milk chocolate person, pull up your straw. In fact, order it as a drink, and you'll still probably have room for one of Lalo's other myriad desserts.
In truth, though some are better than others, I have yet to meet an iced chocolate I don't like. Maybe when Swiss Miss releases a version I'll change my mind. If you know of a good (or bad)frozen cho, lemmeno.